Skip to main content
Lesson 6 of 25

Grammar · Lesson 6

The subjunctive and unreal past

Try it now

You are writing the minutes of a meeting. The client said that the report must be finished by Friday.

Which sentence fits formal minutes?

By the end of this lesson, you can make formal demands with that + base verb, and use past forms for unreal present meaning after it’s time, would rather and as if.

Make formal demands and recommendations with that + base verb, use a past form for present meaning after it’s time, would rather, as if and suppose, and negotiate politely with these forms.

≈ 75–90 minbase-verb subjunctive and past forms with present meaningrecommend that he restit’s time we leftI’d rather you didn’t18+ guided responses
NoticeObserve meaning in context.
DiscoverConnect form, meaning, and use.
BuildChoose and assemble accurate language.
DrillRepair errors and retrieve fluently.
CommunicateUse it for a real purpose.
ReflectCheck control and plan the next use.

Today’s central idea: After verbs and adjectives of demand, advice and importance, formal English uses that + subject + base verb, with no -s and no change for the past. This is the subjunctive. After it’s time, would rather, as if and suppose, a past form describes something unreal or not yet done in the present or future, just like the past in a second conditional.

Warm-up from earlier lessons

Optional, about two minutes. Open it to review what this lesson builds on.

Say each answer before revealing it. The goal is to reactivate language that today’s lesson will extend.

Connect to what you already know

Say a present wish with wish: I / have more time.

Say a second conditional: I / be you / take the job.

Report this advice: “You should rest,” the doctor told me.

Notice before the rule

Verbs that don’t follow the usual rules

Read three sentences from a meeting about a delayed project.

The client has insisted that the report be finished by Friday.

It’s time we stopped making excuses and fixed the problem.

I’d rather you didn’t share these figures outside the team.

  • In the first sentence, why is it be and not is?
  • In the second sentence, is stopped about the past?
  • In the third sentence, when does the speaker want people not to share the figures?

Noticing check

What do the second and third sentences have in common?

Discover the system

After verbs and adjectives of demand, advice and importance, formal English uses that + subject + base verb, with no -s and no change for the past. This is the subjunctive. After it’s time, would rather, as if and suppose, a past form describes something unreal or not yet done in the present or future, just like the past in a second conditional.

PatternFormExample
demand or adviceinsist / recommend / suggest / ask + that + subject + base verbThe doctor recommended that she rest for a week.
importanceIt is essential / vital / important + that + subject + base verbIt is essential that every visitor be registered.
negativethat + subject + not + base verbWe asked that he not share the file.
it’s timeIt’s (high / about) time + subject + past simpleIt’s high time we updated the website.
would ratherwould rather + subject + past simple (now) / past perfect (past)I’d rather you didn’t call me at work.
unreal comparisonas if / as though + past simpleHe talks as if he owned the company.

Meaning and choice

Speaker’s choiceUse it when…Example
that + base verbsomeone wants or requires an actionThey demanded that the city repair the road.
It’s time + pastsomething should already be happeningIt’s about time you called your mother.
would rather + past / past perfecta preference about another person’s actionI’d rather you had asked me first.
suppose / as if + pastan imagined or unreal situationSuppose you lost your job tomorrow, what would you do?

Sound natural: Stress the past verb that carries the message: It’s HIGH time we LEFT. In I’d rather, the contraction is a single syllable, “I’d.” In formal that-clauses, be is stressed lightly: It’s vital that he be told.

High-value repairs

AvoidUseWhy
The manager insisted that he attends the meeting.The manager insisted that he attend the meeting.After insist that, formal English uses the base verb with no -s.
It’s time we go home.It’s time we went home.After it’s time + subject, use a past form for present meaning.
I’d rather you don’t call me at work.I’d rather you didn’t call me at work.Would rather + another subject takes a past form.
We recommend that she doesn’t travel alone.We recommend that she not travel alone.In formal American English, the negative subjunctive is not + base verb.

Base verb or past form?

Look at the word that opens the pattern.

that + base verb

insist, recommend, suggest, demand, ask, requireessential, vital, important, necessary

subject + past form

It’s time / It’s high time / It’s about timewould rather (another person)as if / as though, suppose / supposing

Fixed expressions

Be that as it mayCome what maySo be it

Read language doing real work

Notes from a tenants’ meeting

Decide who wants what, and which situations are real or imagined.

At last night’s tenants’ meeting, several residents demanded that the landlord repair the elevator by the end of the month. One neighbor said it was high time someone took the problem seriously.

The building manager suggested that residents report every breakdown in writing. He added that he would rather people didn’t call him late at night, since he could do nothing until morning.

One resident complained that the landlord behaved as if the building were his private hotel. In the end, the group agreed that it was essential that every complaint be recorded.

Build controlled accuracy

Reusable practice routes

Choose today’s practice set

Choose the set that fits today’s learner. Each set contains different examples.

Core: Secure the central form-and-meaning decisions before increasing the pressure.

The doctor told her to rest for a week. How do you report this formally?

The company website is very old. Which sentence fits?

You don’t want your colleague to mention the news yet. What do you say?

Your colleague made a decision without asking you yesterday. Which sentence fits?

Core set selected.

Build the it’s time sentence

Tell your team that the budget discussion should already have started.

Diagnose and repair

Find the precise problem. A useful correction includes the reason, not only the repaired sentence.

Use the base verb after insist

The manager insisted that he attends the meeting.

Use a past form after it’s time

It’s time we go home.

Fix the preference

I’d rather you don’t call me at work.

Make the formal negative

We recommend that she doesn’t travel alone.

Fluency drill

Respond aloud first. Reveal the model only after you have committed to an answer; your wording can differ if the meaning and form are right.

Transform and expand

Report formally: “You must arrive by eight,” the coach told the players.

Say that something is overdue: we / book the tickets.

Give a polite preference: you / not smoke in the car.

Make an unreal comparison: she acts / be in charge.

Play and practice

Games and a short reading that recycle this lesson. Use them as a warm-up, a fast finisher, or homework. Each one checks itself.

Read

The park on Elm Street

Read once for meaning. Then read again and do the tasks below.

Meeting report116 wordsAbout 1 min

The neighborhood association met on Tuesday to discuss the park on Elm Street. Several members demanded that the city repair the broken lights before winter, and one insisted that the playground be closed until the equipment is checked.

“It’s high time we started taking care of this place ourselves,” said Rosa, who has lived on the street for thirty years. Others agreed, but they said they would rather the city paid for the work, since residents already pay taxes for it.

Mr. Patel complained that some dog owners behave as if the park were their private garden. In the end, the chair suggested that everyone join a cleanup day on the first Saturday of the month.

Find it

Tap the 6 verbs in the subjunctive or the unreal past, like arrive in “We ask that guests arrive early.”

Check your understanding

1. What did members want the city to do before winter?

2. Why do some residents want the city to pay?

3. What did the chair suggest?

Sort it

Which pattern is it?

Tap a word, then tap the box it belongs in. Press Check when the tray is empty.

Match up

Say it the advanced way

Tap an item on the left, then its partner on the right.

Everyday version

Advanced version

Crossword

Subjunctive and unreal past in context

Tap a clue or a square, then type. Press Check when you finish.

Across

Down

Choose the right amount of challenge

Communicate in three steps

The house meeting. Pick one starting point, then move up only if the learner is ready. True or invented details are equally acceptable.

1

Personal answer

Make the language yours

Use the lesson’s earlier example or invent a similar situation. The details do not need to be personal.

Two roommates meet to agree on new house rules after a difficult month. Start with this cue: What do you insist that the other person do?

Next cues
  • What is it high time you both changed?
  • What would you rather the other person didn’t do?
2

Guided role play

The house meeting

Two roommates meet to agree on new house rules after a difficult month.

Role 1Roommate A: you want stricter rules. Use insist that, it’s essential that and it’s time.

Role 2Roommate B: you want more freedom. Use I’d rather you, suppose and as if to push back politely.

Useful language
  • What do you insist that the other person do?
  • What is it high time you both changed?
  • What would you rather the other person didn’t do?
  • Suppose one of you broke a rule. What should happen?
3

Real-world challenge

Remove the support

Write 180 to 220 words of recommendations after a problem at work, school or in your building.

C1 target: Sustain a clear position for two minutes, adapt to a challenge, and reformulate one point more precisely.

Include
  • Use recommend, insist or suggest + that + base verb at least twice.
  • Use it is essential that or it is vital that once.
  • Use it’s time and would rather once each.

Practicing on your own? Say every step out loud, and time yourself on step 3. The site can’t hear you, so for feedback on how you actually sound, book a speaking lesson with Thomas.

Write for a real reader

Write the recommendations

Write 180 to 220 words of recommendations after a problem at work, school or in your building.

Your text must

  • Use recommend, insist or suggest + that + base verb at least twice.
  • Use it is essential that or it is vital that once.
  • Use it’s time and would rather once each.

Reveal a possible model only after you have drafted your own version.

Reflect and transfer

Can you do this without the page?

  • Use that + base verb after verbs and adjectives of demand, advice and importance.
  • Use a past form for present meaning after it’s time, would rather, as if and suppose.
  • Make formal requests and polite preferences in a negotiation.

Your next use: In your next email or meeting, use one that-clause with a base verb and one sentence with I’d rather you. Return to the retrieval bridge next lesson.

Revision · about 5 minutes

Test yourself

Up to ten mixed questions on The subjunctive and unreal past: choose the answer, find the mistake, put words in order, or spell the word. Try it at the end of the lesson, or a few days later to see what stayed.

Keep going

Make this lesson stick

Daily Practice · freePractice this lessonFive-minute C1 sessions. The questions you miss come back until they stick.Anki flashcards · freeMake a deck from this lessonDownload this lesson’s questions as flashcards for the free Anki app, and review them anywhere.Self-study guides · from US$12Fix the mistakes your first language causesThinking in Portuguese, False Friends at Work, and more: the English mistakes professionals make at work, and why.One-on-one with ThomasBook your first lessonBring this topic to a live lesson and practice it out loud with an American tutor.

Spot a mistake on this page? Tell me