Can we trust online reviews?

You’re listening to a consumer podcast. The host asks how much weight we should give to online reviews.

Share this scene

Before you listen

Talk about it first.

  1. Do you read reviews before you buy something or book a hotel? Which ones do you trust?
  2. Have you ever written a review? What made you write it?

Listen for these words

You will hear

Granted
Used to admit that something is true before making a contrasting point.
glowing
Extremely positive and full of praise.
skewed
Not balanced or accurate, because one side is overrepresented.
Be wary of
Be careful about; don’t trust easily.
the whole story
All the facts, not just part of them.

C1 Advanced · Podcast · About 1.5 minutes

Listen

Listen once for the main idea. Then answer, and listen again for the details. Don’t read the transcript yet.

Step 1 · Main idea

What is it about?

Listen once, all the way through. Then choose the best answer.

01What is Rachel’s main message?

Step 2 · Details

Listen again for the details

Read the questions first, then play the recording again. Pause when you need to.

01Why are even honest reviews skewed?

02Why does Rachel suggest starting with three-star reviews?

03Why does Rachel mention “how loud the motor is”?

04What does the comparison with a stranger at a party suggest?

Show the transcript

Welcome to The Informed Buyer. I’m Rachel Moss. Before you book a hotel or buy a blender, you probably check the reviews. But how much should we actually trust them?

Granted, reviews are far better than nothing. That said, the system has obvious weaknesses. Some businesses pay for glowing reviews or offer discounts in return for five stars. And even honest reviews are skewed: people who had a terrible experience are far more motivated to write than those who were simply satisfied.

So how should you read them? Start with the three-star reviews. They tend to be the most balanced, because the writer had no reason to exaggerate. Be wary of a sudden burst of praise posted within the same week, and look for specific details rather than vague enthusiasm. A review that says “life-changing!” tells you far less than one that mentions how loud the motor is.

None of this means you should ignore reviews altogether. Treat them like advice from a stranger at a party: interesting, occasionally useful, and never the whole story.

Now play the recording and read along. Then try saying it with the speaker, at the same speed.

Speak

Your turn

Give a friend advice on how to judge something they read online, such as a review or a news story. Start with a concession (“Granted, …”), then add a counterargument (“That said, …”).

Spot a mistake on this page? Tell me