Should museums give objects back?

A weekly arts program on public radio opens with a short feature on a long-running debate.

Share this scene

Before you listen

Talk about it first.

  1. Have you seen objects in a museum that came from another country? How did they get there?
  2. Who do you think has the strongest claim to an important historical object?

Listen for these words

You will hear

charged
Full of strong emotion and likely to cause argument.
at best
Even in the most positive view; used to show something is not good.
the argument goes
Used to report what supporters of a view say, without saying you agree.
for their part
As far as they are concerned; used to introduce another group’s view.
case by case
Separately for each situation, not by one general rule.

C1 Advanced · Radio · About 1.5 minutes

Listen

Listen once for the main idea. Then answer, and listen again for the details. Don’t read the transcript yet.

Step 1 · Main idea

What is it about?

Listen once, all the way through. Then choose the best answer.

01What does the feature mainly do?

Step 2 · Details

Listen again for the details

Read the questions first, then play the recording again. Pause when you need to.

01Why do supporters of return describe consent as questionable?

02What does “less a gift than an overdue correction” suggest?

03Which concern do critics raise?

04How does the presenter signal her own view about the future of the debate?

Show the transcript

This week on The Culture Desk, we turn to a question that has moved from academic journals to the front pages: should museums return objects to the countries they were taken from? Few debates in the art world are quite so charged, and the answers are rarely as simple as either side suggests.

Those in favor of return tend to argue that many objects were acquired during periods of conquest or colonial rule, when consent was, at best, questionable. For the communities they came from, such objects may carry religious or historical meaning that no display case can convey. Returning them, the argument goes, is less a gift than an overdue correction.

Critics of large-scale returns, for their part, raise concerns that deserve to be taken seriously. Some worry about whether fragile pieces can be safely transported and cared for. Others suggest that seeing many cultures side by side arguably has value of its own.

What seems increasingly likely is that the debate will be settled case by case rather than by a single rule.

Now play the recording and read along. Then try saying it with the speaker, at the same speed.

Speak

Your turn

Present both sides of a debate in your country in about one minute. Report each side fairly using phrases such as “tend to argue,” “the argument goes,” and “for their part.”

Spot a mistake on this page? Tell me