You might hear
The meeting has been canceled yesterday.
Natural English
Apparently the meeting was canceled yesterday.
Why it happens
The Turkish pattern behind it
Turkish can grammatically mark that past information is reported, inferred, or newly discovered. English has no single equivalent ending, so speakers choose evidence phrases and stance verbs such as apparently, reportedly, seems, must have, or I was told. Carrying -miş over as has plus a past participle does not work with a finished time such as yesterday; use the past simple with the evidence phrase.
- In Turkish
- Duydun mu? Ahmet işten ayrılmış.
- Word for word
- You heard? Ahmet from job left-reportedly.
- Natural English
- Did you hear? Apparently, Ahmet quit his job.
More natural examples
- The figures must have been copied from an older report.
- Apparently, the committee changed its decision overnight.
Not every Turkish speaker makes this mistake. If you hear yourself say it more than once, it’s worth practicing.
Speaking drills
Say it right, out loud
Three drills, from easy to harder. Say each answer out loud first, then open it to check.
1 Fix it
Each sentence has the mistake. Say it correctly.
I heard the new manager has started on Monday.
Check
I heard the new manager started on Monday.
Someone told me our neighbors have moved out last weekend.
Check
Someone told me our neighbors moved out last weekend.
Apparently the store has closed early yesterday.
Check
Apparently the store closed early yesterday.
2 Build it
Report each piece of news with the phrase given. Use a past form for a finished time.
apparently / the flight / be delayed / two hours yesterday
Check
Apparently the flight was delayed two hours yesterday.
I was told / the client / sign the contract / on Friday
Check
I was told the client signed the contract on Friday.
must have / someone / leave the door open / last night
Check
Someone must have left the door open last night.
3 Your turn
Answer and show how you know. Use apparently, I was told, I heard, or it seems.
What news did you hear recently that you didn’t see yourself?
See a model answer
Apparently my old school closed last year. A friend told me about it.
What happened at work or at home while you were away?
See a model answer
I was told the team moved to a new office while I was on vacation. It seems the move went well.
For teachers: a quick way to practice this
Give the same event with direct observation, a colleague’s report, and an inference from evidence; require a different English stance frame for each source.
Want someone to catch the mistakes you don’t notice? In a lesson I listen for your patterns and we fix them together. Book a lesson with Thomas
Spot a mistake on this page? Tell me