A finished time needs the past simple

A common mistake for French speakers · A2 Elementary · Tenses

You might hear

I have seen him yesterday.

We have signed the contract last week.

Natural English

I saw him yesterday.

We signed the contract last week.

Why it happens

The French pattern behind it

The French passé composé looks like the English present perfect, but in everyday speech it is the normal tense for finished events. English separates the two: a finished time such as yesterday, last week, or in 2022 selects the past simple, while the present perfect connects the past to now.

In French
J’ai rencontré ma nouvelle collègue hier.
Word for word
I have met my new colleague yesterday.
Natural English
I met my new colleague yesterday.

More natural examples

  • We moved to Montreal in 2021.
  • I’ve already sent the file, so you can check it now.

Not every French speaker makes this mistake. If you hear yourself say it more than once, it’s worth practicing.

Speaking drills

Say it right, out loud

Three drills, from easy to harder. Say each answer out loud first, then open it to check.

1 Fix it

Each sentence has the mistake. Say it correctly.

  1. I have met my husband in 2012.

    Check

    I met my husband in 2012.

  2. Have you seen the news last night?

    Check

    Did you see the news last night?

  3. They have arrived two hours ago.

    Check

    They arrived two hours ago.

2 Build it

Say what happened. Use the past simple with the time phrase.

  1. we / go / to Italy / last summer

    Check

    We went to Italy last summer.

  2. I / finish / the report / on Tuesday

    Check

    I finished the report on Tuesday.

  3. when / you / start / this job? (question)

    Check

    When did you start this job?

3 Your turn

Answer with full sentences.

  1. What did you do last night?

    See a model answer

    I cooked dinner and watched a movie with my partner.

  2. When did you last travel abroad, and where did you go?

    See a model answer

    I went to Morocco in April for a friend’s wedding.

For teachers: a quick way to practice this

Read out time expressions one by one, such as yesterday, ever, last Monday, and already, and have the learner choose saw or have seen before completing the sentence.

Want someone to catch the mistakes you don’t notice? In a lesson I listen for your patterns and we fix them together. Book a lesson with Thomas

Spot a mistake on this page? Tell me