A finished time normally selects past simple

A common mistake for Italian speakers · A2 Elementary · Tenses

You might hear

Yesterday I have seen a great film.

Natural English

Yesterday I saw a great film.

Why it happens

The Italian pattern behind it

In everyday Italian, the passato prossimo is the normal tense for finished events, even with ieri or l’anno scorso. Its form looks like the English present perfect, but English uses the past simple whenever a finished time such as yesterday or last year is stated or understood.

In Italian
Ieri sera ho finito il progetto.
Word for word
Yesterday evening I have finished the project.
Natural English
I finished the project last night.

More natural examples

  • We moved to Bologna in 2021.
  • I’ve already sent the file, so you can check it now.

Not every Italian speaker makes this mistake. If you hear yourself say it more than once, it’s worth practicing.

Speaking drills

Say it right, out loud

Three drills, from easy to harder. Say each answer out loud first, then open it to check.

1 Fix it

Each sentence has the mistake. Say it correctly.

  1. Last summer we have gone to Greece.

    Check

    Last summer we went to Greece.

  2. I have met my wife in 2010.

    Check

    I met my wife in 2010.

  3. She has called me an hour ago.

    Check

    She called me an hour ago.

2 Build it

Say what happened. Use the past simple with the time given.

  1. I / see / the doctor / on Monday

    Check

    I saw the doctor on Monday.

  2. we / buy / our apartment / in 2019

    Check

    We bought our apartment in 2019.

  3. my team / finish / the report / yesterday

    Check

    My team finished the report yesterday.

3 Your turn

Answer with full sentences.

  1. What did you do last weekend?

    See a model answer

    I visited my parents on Saturday, and I went to a concert on Sunday.

  2. When did you start your current job?

    See a model answer

    I started my current job three years ago, in September.

For teachers: a quick way to practice this

Read sentences with time phrases such as yesterday, last summer, already, and ever, and have the learner pick past simple or present perfect, naming the time phrase that decided it.

Want someone to catch the mistakes you don’t notice? In a lesson I listen for your patterns and we fix them together. Book a lesson with Thomas

Spot a mistake on this page? Tell me